I think the term open-minded can sometimes mean two separate things. It can mean teachable and it can also mean hopelessly confused. I think teachability is essential. No one likes people who are unwilling to learn. If you are teachable, people are drawn to you. Being teachable is the only way to get a job, the only way to build relationships and the only way to grow in Christ .
But sometimes we confuse having an open mind with not believing anything/ believing everything you hear. Not believing and believing everything are the exact same thing because they both leave you like a boat in a hurricane. What happens to boats in hurricane? How well can you steer a boat when waves have half of the boat out of the water? Not useful at all because it has no control. The Bible tells us that sometimes we can be like that when don’t have any foundation of truth (Ephesians 4:11-15). The reality is there are a lot of ideas and lifestyles that can’t all be good. How do we know which ones are good for us?
2 Timothy 1:4 says this “Guard the good deposit that was entrusted to you—guard it with the help of the Holy Spirit who lives in us.” If you are a Christian, then you have been given a task to guard the good truth that you have. Why? Because it can get stolen from you. It happens when we let our guard down and allow ourselves to be lied to about things that we know are true.
I have hung out with numerous students in my 5 years as a leader at Vox. I have seen tons of students meet with God, hear God or see God do something amazing and yet- years later they don’t know if they even still believe in God. The crazy thing is that they knew God and knew that He was as real as you and I. But at some point, they let their guard down and lies came in to steal the truth that was there.
When you begin to experience doubts, the best way to guard your heart is to look back and remember what you know to be true. For me, I look back to all the times God has answered my prayers, to times that I have seen God move powerfully, to the places I have been where I saw God heal people physically, and to all the times I’ve heard God speak to me. Those memories become my shield against lies. Pray and ask God’s Holy Spirit to help you. The Bible says he brings all things back to your memory.
Always be teachable- but never drop your guard.